Taxes… worse than strip clubs?
Unfortunately, despite the fact that I was in New Haven on business anyway, I was unable to attend the Masters Club v. East Hartford case in court today. The New Haven Federal District Court requires you to check your cell phones at the door and I could not be separated from my phones during business hours. I’ve not heard any updates yet from either side either.
What I did instead was go to the Raymond Library to conduct some budgetary research for a tax reform proposal I’m working on. What I found was two fold. First, the reference section has a woefully inadequate resource of town budget documents. Quite frankly, there is no where near the information required for an average resident to form a working knowledge of the budget history of East Hartford. I won’t judge too harshly however because the regular reference librarian is on vacation. There may be more information squirreled away which the other librarians don’t know about.
What I did find was interesting. The most interesting part being that student enrollment in the East Hartford School District totalled 7,438 in 1998 and increased to 7,918 in 2007 which represents a 6.4% increase in enrollment. During the same period the employment rolls of the East Hartford School District increased from 934 in 1998 to 1222 in 2007, or 30.8%. Is it any wonder why our school budget is spiralling out of control?
How much does the average employee make? According to the 08/09 BOE proposed budget the answer is $53,315 before benefits. The budgetary impact of these 288 additional employees is huge. Based on the 08/09 adopted budget’s mill rate calculation these employees represent 4.98 mills of the current 31.67 mills. In plain dollars and cents that’s $721.62 that the average taxpayer has no choice but to pay.
What was it that Bill Horan and Barbara Rossi said at budget time earlier this year? They said that taxes don’t cause foreclosures. Well, I’ll counter that by saying when this kind of unchecked excess represents $60/month extra on the “average” persons mortgage and tax increases of 5% or greater come year after year the result is the inability of the homeowner to pay the mortgage and the taxes. The average East Hartford taxpayer today has a burden before state and federal taxes of $382/month.
It can be assumed based on previous unbridled budgetary growth that when budget season ‘09 concludes the monthly tax burden will be over $400 while the median household income in East Hartford remains stagnant or falls and the grand list shrinks.
Stay tuned, major changes for the East Hartford tax system are coming. With any luck these changes will force the BoE to realize it’s strangling this town and they’ll fix these problems voluntarily. If not, we’ll drag them kicking and screaming to an education system that this town can afford.
UPDATE: I did manage to find the exhibits and witness lists filed by the town and Masters Club. When you put them together you get a pretty good idea of what is being argued in court.
East Hartford (Defendant) Exhibit List
East Hartford (Defendant) Witness List
Masters Club (Plaintiff) Exhibit List
Masters Club (Plaintiff) Witness List
My $5 says the Masters Club case is two pronged.
The first prong is an attempt to demonstrate through testimony of Council & P&Z members as well as town officials that certain persons, whether in executive session or out, have indicated that the goal is to prevent clubs from coming to town. *cough* Currey *cough* Any such statement by a town official would likely lose the case right there since it is illegal for the town to regulate speech for reasons other than secondary effects.
The second prong will be ripping apart the claims of regulating for secondary effects. As you’ll see on the witness list a variety of people not named on the case have been subpoenaed to testify in addition to P&Z members. I don’t honestly believe the claim of regulating for secondary effects can be defended here, but good luck to Mr. Gerard.
On the defense side it appears their strategy is to disqualify as much of the plaintiff’s exhibit material as possible followed by an attempt to get Mr. Chu and or his real estate agent to blow the case and finally a vigorous defense of the actions of the P&Z and town hall officials to date as regulating for secondary effects.
I’m anxious to see the resolution of this preliminary injunction hearing and find out if everyone told the truth up on the stand based on what has been told to me over the months. If you are interested here is the relief that Masters Club is seeking.
Related Posts: